News:

SMF - Just Installed!

Main Menu

Is copying cards tourney legal?

Started by DaveW, October 27, 2017, 10:19:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

DaveW

I sometimes need to make copies of my cards. I have been doing what was mentioned in another post (http://forum.arcanewonders.com/index.php?topic=14047.msg38027#msg38027) to do this. They are pretty well indistinguishable from a "real" spell card.

Is doing this legal for official tournaments?

For example, I lost a Warlord book that had four Hurl Boulders in it... and now I don't have very many of them. Can I copy one of my remaining ones and use the copies in a tournament legally?

Another example: Some products (thinking Academy decks in particular) do not include enough cards in a single package to put that maximum number of copies of a spell in an Arena book. Can I, for example, make three copies of the Wychwood Hound and use six in a spellbook even though I only own three?

This brings up a related question. Must I actually own the spells to use them? Let's say I don't purchase one particular product, but a friend has. He lends me a copy to put in a tourney book. There is no way to tell that I do not actually own that copy. If photocopies are legal, then all you need to do is to copy your friend's card.

Also, I haven't tried it, but I suppose someone could find a way to copy cards from an online source, print out some to use, and never actually own the spell (or game?) at all. Is this a reason to disallow photocopies in official tournaments?

A really odd situation might arise if copies are not allowed. Let's say one of my Acid Ball copies ends up in a book that I take to GenCon. I have plenty of the cards available at home... it's just that the one that I happened to include in my spell book is a copy. What happens? Is the book disallowed? Do I just play without the spell? I guess this one depends on the TD... but I'm curious what you all think.

Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

zot

While I am not sure about the copying of cards, I suspect that will not be allowed. But lending of cards is perfectly fine. I know I have lent cards to folks for tournaments the last few years.

silverclawgrizzly

Copying wouldn't be allowed but lending is. Note the card pool provided at Gen Con.
What we must all remember is no matter the game we were all newbies at one point.

Beldin

Copying cards would make Proxy cards. Proxies should never be allowed at tournaments. However I have lent cards to people before the events. This is totally legal.