I know that part bro, that's just solid play. Im talking about what finisher just makes you happiest! The one that makes you gleeful. But if that's what makes you tick, that's cool. Nothing wrong with looking for the best ends by the best means.
I have no preference beyond the tightest play and the highest win percentage...
Could you explain what you mean by this? Maybe with an example or two.
Im guessing you mean "tight" the same way as Poker players do: safe, solid, good maybe even best play at any possible time.
Highest win percentage seems hard to calculate.
Are you going to try to kill him in this round or are you just going to try to put more damage on him - putting him closer to death or are you trying to prevent him from doing something.
Normally you dont know your opponents spellbook or his 2 planned cards.
You are trying to make an educated guess on whats hes going to do and act on that.
Ideally you would want to do something he cant defend against.
And if your behind you might just try to turn things, even if it has a very low chance of success.