Hi Everybody,
I'm brand new to the game and found this thread. Thanks for finding a creative solution!
I have an update to the info in here.
1st - The boards are still available at Target for around $3.50 or so. I expect there to be three MW players in our household as well as friends. So I picked up four of them.
2nd - The round magnets are also there. One pack is around $4 and has 16 magnets. This works out for four players as each can have 3 of one color, and another color for damage. That being said I'll probably return them. See number 3.
3rd - I could not find push pins in the colors mentioned at Office Depot. I was able to find similar ones at Staples. There are 10/pack with 5 colors (red, blue, green, yellow, black). It's $4/pack. I also found a store brand version with brighter colors for $3.50. I opted for the darker colors. 2 packs gives me options for multiple players in our house. These hold the status boards pretty well. I can't pick the board up by the pins, but I can hold the board upside down and shake it a bit. The pins don't move. They hold better than the target round magnets and are normal push pin shape. Also, the colors "feel" better.
Here's a link to the pins I bought:
http://www.staples.com/Quartet-Magnetic-Push-Pins-High-Power-Magnets-Bright-Colors-10-Pack/product_614048If links aren't allowed then search for quartet magnetic push pins. I found them hanging in the section of the store with dry erase boards.