Can Jinx counter Seeking Dispel?

[Mestrahd]

I certainly hope you didn't think I was starting a flame war.

[theduke850]

I didn't think you were.

and you were correct about Jinx refunding the casters mana, an oversight on my part saying it was a moot point.

hopefully all questions have been explained by shadows detailed breakdown.

[Shad0w]

And the question is not "moot" because if Seeking Dispel is the one resolving it's that controller paying the mana and not the Jinx controller. If Jinx went off, then the Seeking Dispel's controller would get a refund.

It just came across as curt. I assumed it was not what you intended so I wanted to stop a flame war before it stated. Do not worry about it. I am in no way upset but I know how things can get taken the wrong to far too often.

[Mestrahd]

I guess the quotation marks do look curt. But I was just using his word. No disrespect intended. Merely pointing out that the payment of mana (or refund) relied on the answer.

[Scarob]

Shadow that was a fantastic explanation, I at least understand how it works now.......thankies XD - id karma you if i could XD il have to wait to get the option back lol