91
Player Feedback and Suggestions / Re: Best/Ugliest Card Artwork
« on: August 19, 2014, 03:59:11 PM »
Due to the nature of Mage Wars, a lot of cards (while impressive and well-drawn) look stereotypical and therefore made less of an impact on me (since they weren't surprising). Therefore, a lot of my favorite artwork are things that surprised me.
Best:
Blood Demon - Unlike many of the previous demons, these guys actually look terrifying. The semi-hidden mouths on their bodies, arms, and legs make them even more distinctive (and frightening).
Infernian Scourger - Similar to the blood demons, these look distinctive, demonic, and intimidating.
Iron Golem - I've seen a fair amount of golem artwork, but these are undoubtedly among the best. The earth elemental looks extremely tame in comparison.
Mana Leech - I think the most striking thing about this card is that it is impossible to tell the size of the creature. It's probably fairly small (leeches typically are), but I like to think it's the size of a house. The spikes (and tentacles?) all over its body are also a nice touch.
Samandriel - I know, I know; it's a scantily clad female. Just hear me out. I think the flavor text and name of the card are extremely important to appreciating this artwork. My opinion is that this card carries its theme better than any other card in the game. Everything in the artwork is blindingly bright, from the sword to the armor, to the angel's wings, to the glow emanating from the center of the background. Just looking at the card is enough to make my eyes water occasionally. Plus, angels are typically shown as lightly covered (especially in older art, where they were usually either naked or covered by a sheet). So I'm inclined to give this card some leeway.
Worst:
Priestess - She looks like a belly dancer. What kind of priestess walks around with partially transparent clothes and a top held together by two pieces of string?! Lastly, what is up with her insanely long cuffs? Those things have got to be dragging across the ground constantly.
Knight of Westlock - Most of the card is fine, but that sword looks like a child's plastic toy. Somebody needs to give that thing one of Sir Corazin's swords.
Guardian Angel - Why would anyone try to go for both a heavily-armored look and a chain-mail bikini at the same time?! Pick one or the other. This also just makes the whole issue of scantily clad angels worse. Be consistent!
Some thoughts on the cards listed in the OP: I agree for the most part, but I'm fairly certain the "lightning" on the Libro Mortus card is supposed to be ethereal or death energy. The statue on the Battle Forge card looks like a dwarf without a long beard to me, but now I will forever also see a wookie. Why would you do this to me?
Best:
Blood Demon - Unlike many of the previous demons, these guys actually look terrifying. The semi-hidden mouths on their bodies, arms, and legs make them even more distinctive (and frightening).
Infernian Scourger - Similar to the blood demons, these look distinctive, demonic, and intimidating.
Iron Golem - I've seen a fair amount of golem artwork, but these are undoubtedly among the best. The earth elemental looks extremely tame in comparison.
Mana Leech - I think the most striking thing about this card is that it is impossible to tell the size of the creature. It's probably fairly small (leeches typically are), but I like to think it's the size of a house. The spikes (and tentacles?) all over its body are also a nice touch.
Samandriel - I know, I know; it's a scantily clad female. Just hear me out. I think the flavor text and name of the card are extremely important to appreciating this artwork. My opinion is that this card carries its theme better than any other card in the game. Everything in the artwork is blindingly bright, from the sword to the armor, to the angel's wings, to the glow emanating from the center of the background. Just looking at the card is enough to make my eyes water occasionally. Plus, angels are typically shown as lightly covered (especially in older art, where they were usually either naked or covered by a sheet). So I'm inclined to give this card some leeway.
Worst:
Priestess - She looks like a belly dancer. What kind of priestess walks around with partially transparent clothes and a top held together by two pieces of string?! Lastly, what is up with her insanely long cuffs? Those things have got to be dragging across the ground constantly.
Knight of Westlock - Most of the card is fine, but that sword looks like a child's plastic toy. Somebody needs to give that thing one of Sir Corazin's swords.
Guardian Angel - Why would anyone try to go for both a heavily-armored look and a chain-mail bikini at the same time?! Pick one or the other. This also just makes the whole issue of scantily clad angels worse. Be consistent!
Some thoughts on the cards listed in the OP: I agree for the most part, but I'm fairly certain the "lightning" on the Libro Mortus card is supposed to be ethereal or death energy. The statue on the Battle Forge card looks like a dwarf without a long beard to me, but now I will forever also see a wookie. Why would you do this to me?